| Introduction While there are many
well-documented advantages of a vegetarian diet,
it is also true that a vegetarian diet must be
done skilfully and with knowledge of how to
provide complete nutrition for the body. If one
eats a well-balanced and well-cooked diet of
fresh and whole foods and avoids fats and refined
sugars, most nutritional requirements will easily
be met. There are a few nutrients which are
likely to be deficient in vegetarians, however,
especially in those vegetarians who are in
transition from a meat-based diet. The purpose of
this chapter is to discuss three of these common
pitfalls: iron, zinc, and Bl2.
Iron
An
appreciation of the importance of iron in the
diet goes back further than perhaps that of any
other mineral. The ancients thought of it as a
carrier, and it was identified with the planet
Mars, perhaps because of the distinctive redness
of Mars. Iron has a tendency to take up oxygen
readily, changing its colour to red. This is the
basis for its function in the blood, where it is
the carrier of oxygen to the tissues of the body.
Iron's
tendency to take up oxygen comes from its curious
ability to change valencesit can have
either two or three electrical charges. This
means it can, by altering itself from one state
to the other, take up or let go of an extra
oxygen atom. Because of this ability, iron is the
centre of the body's oxygen transport system,
which is based on hemoglobin. Hemoglobin is a
giant complex molecule which contains, like a
tiny jewel in the centre of each of its four
basic components, a single atom of iron. This
iron in the centre of the hemoglobin molecule
accepts the oxygen and as it does so develops the
bright red colour which differentiates oxygenated
blood from the dark red or bluish blood of the
veins.
Anemia,
which is a relative lack of red blood cells,
usually shows up as tiredness, fatigue, paleness,
and a tendency to dizziness on standing. Although
many other substances besides iron are also
necessary to build red blood cells, iron
deficiency is one of the most common causes of
anemia.
Many
nutritionists are concerned that vegetarians may
be at special risk for iron-deficiency anemia.
These fears are not unfounded; in fact a number
of cases of such anemia have been reported among
vegetarians. Although iron has been shown by
surveys to be low in diets of many populations,
some groups within any population are at
particular risk. These include infants, because
of the low iron content of milk; children and
adolescents, because of their rapid growth; and
women during their reproductive years, both
because of blood losses during menstruation and
because of the demands of pregnancy. For such
persons, moving toward a vegetarian diet requires
special attention to the issue of iron.
There is no
question that red meat, such as beef, is richer
in iron than many other foods. (See table below.)
Yet it is also clear that many plant foods, such
as beans and green leafy vegetables, may equal or
surpass red meat in iron content.
| Food |
Amount |
Iron(mg) |
| Blood
Sausage |
3oz |
17.0 |
| Liver,Beef |
3oz |
7.5 |
| Beef,sirloin |
3oz |
2.5 |
| Fish(Halibut) |
3oz |
0.6 |
| Eggs |
1(Large) |
1.2 |
| Milk(Whole) |
1 cup |
0.1 |
| Kidney
beans |
1/2 cup |
3.4 |
| Lentils |
1/2 cup |
2.1 |
| Navy
beans |
1/2 cup |
2.1 |
| Whole-wheat
bread |
1 piece |
1.0 |
| Spinach* |
3/4 cup |
2.3 |
| Kale* |
3/4 cup |
1.7 |
| Collards* |
3/4 cup |
0.6 |
| Raisins |
2 T |
0.6 |
| Molasses |
2 T |
2.0 |
*
Cooked in own broth until water evaporates ( not
drained ).
Sources
: Truesdell et al: Nutrients in Vegetarian Foods.
U.S. Dept of Agriculture: Nutritive value of
American Foods.
Davidson et al: Human Nutrition and Dietetics.
The problem
is in the different absorption rates of iron from
meat versus iron from plant foods. Half or more
of the iron in muscle meats such as beef is of a
sort that nutritionists refer to as
"heme" iron. It is found in hemoglobin,
the molecule in blood that turns red on picking
up oxygen, and in myoglobin, the pigment that
makes muscle tissues red. Heme iron, in the form
of iron-containing fragments of the hemoglobin
and myoglobin molecules, crosses the intestinal
wall intact. This seems both to accelerate the
absorption of the iron and to protect it from
being picked up by and bound to substances in the
diet which form compounds with iron. For this
reason heme iron is absorbed at a rate of from
25% to 35% of what is ingested.
By
contrast, iron absorption from plant foods
usually runs in the 2% to 10 range. Certain
iron-binding substances in plant foods, such as
the fiber in fruits and vegetables, the phytates
of grains, or the oxalic acid in spinach, have
been observed to bind iron, and are thus thought
to carry it out of the body, preventing the
absorption of much of what is present.
Happily,
however, recent studies have taught us more about
the subtleties of iron absorption from non-meat
foods. Contrary to earlier opinions, new work has
shown that oxalates and most of the fiber in
fruits and vegetables, when taken in moderate
amounts, do not interfere with iron absorption in
the living body, though some of them may bind
iron in the test tube. Phytates, indigestible
substances especially concentrated in the bran
layer of whole grains, remain controversial. It
has been shown in the case of calcium that the
intestine can develop the ability to break down
phytates, thus freeing the mineral bound by them.
Current research has not yet demonstrated
conclusively whether the intestine can develop
the ability to break down the phytate which binds
iron, but is true that other components of bran
such as its phosphates, do seem to inhibit iron
absorption.
However,
the effects of one previously suspected inhibitor
have definitely been confirmed: that of tea.
Black tea is a very potent obstacle to the
assimilation of iron. This effect comes from the
tannic acid in the tea, which combines with the
iron to form an insoluble compound. For this
reasons tea probably should not be taken along
with meals, although it is possible that some of
the traditional additives such as mink or lemon
may neutralize the tannic acid and reduce its
interference with iron absorption.
Boosting
Available Vegetarian Iron
One of the
most interesting and important discoveries about
iron is that its absorption from grains and
legumes can be greatly enhanced by the presence
of ascorbic acid (vitamin C). Vitamin C is
plentiful in such foods as tomatoes, green
peppers, turmeric, and lemons. A recent report
states: "The effect of ascorbic acid on
non-heme iron absorption has been tested in a
number of dietary settings and in every case has
been shown to be profound. It plays a
particularly critical role in diets in which
lithe or no meat is present. Non-heme iron
absorption in one study was quadrupled by
including in the meal enough vegetables to
provide 65 milligrams of vitamin C. This amount
is exceeded by a cup of broccoli or half a green
pepper.
Green leafy
vegetables, which are often high in both iron and
vitamin C, can be exceptionally good sources of
dietary iron. Favourite non-meat recipes in many
parts of the world make generous use of
ingredients rich in vitamin C, such as tomatoes,
green peppers, or hot chillies. This is
especially true of bean dishes, and it is
interesting to discover that legumes such as
lentils, beans and peas have recently been
recognized as being particularly rich in iron.
The potential use of ascorbic acid to facilitate
the assimilation of such iron makes it a valuable
source of this mineral for the vegetarian. Lactic
acid (in yogurt) has been thought to play a
similar role, but other acids probably don't.
Vitamin
C Content of Foods Often Used in Vegetarian Meals
| Food |
Vitamin C
mg. per 1/2 cup |
| Onion |
5 |
| Green Beans |
9 |
| Potato |
10 |
| Tomato |
25 |
| Spinach |
25 |
| Mustard
Greens |
38 |
| Broccoli |
50 |
| Kale |
75 |
| Green Peppers |
90 |
| Lemon Juice |
1T = 7mg. |
|

|
Source
: Nutritive value of American
Foods.
There are
other tricks for boosting the iron available in
non-meat foods. For example, it has been shown
that the iron from pots and skillets can add
significantly to absorbable iron in the diet. It
is leached from the inside of the pot and
combines with the food. Available iron in food
can be increased by 100% to 400- when it is
prepared in iron cookware. This effect might even
be excessive when very acidic dishes, such as
concentrated tomato sauce, are prepared in iron
cookware. In that case, the inside of the cooking
utensil will lose its shiny surface and the food
will become darkened and develop an unpleasant
metallic taste. Regular consumption of such food
could eventually lead to iron overload. Although
a certain amount of iron from cooking utensils is
helpful, too much can cause iron to accumulate in
tissues and cause illness. Very little iron is
carried over into the food when non-acidic dishes
are cooked in ironware, especially if some
cooking fat is present. Thus, an appropriate rule
of thumb for a vegetarian would be to cook about
half his food, (an assortment of dishes, but not
very acidic ones) in iron pots and pans. A heavy
iron skillet with beans, peppers and tomatoes
simmering away may be appetizing in part because
of the satisfaction of iron that it suggests.
Minerals often compete with one another for
absorption. Foods very high in calcium can
interfere with the absorption of other minerals,
such as zinc. Too much milk, which is high in
calcium and low in iron, can block iron intake.
Researchers
who have studied the iron levels of long-term
vegetarians have demonstrated that iron and
hemoglobin levels were within normal levels.
These researchers termed the results
"surprising", and suggested that the
vegetarians had somehow adapted their diet in
such a way as to enable them to increase their
efficiency of iron absorption. It seems
reasonable to postulate that long-term
vegetarians can handle the iron in plant foods
differently from persons accustomed to mixed meat
and vegetable diets. In any case, it seems clear
that one need not become iron deficient on a
meat-free diet. Following are the main points to
remember in obtaining optimum dietary iron:
- The
well-planned vegetarian diet (based on
whole grains, beans and green vegetables)
has as much iron as the average
meat-based diet but it is less readily
absorbed.
- Absorption
can be increased (up to five-fold), by
including in the meals, fruits and
vegetables rich in vitamin C.
- The
iron content of the diet can be doubled,
tripled or quadrupled by using iron pots
and skillets.
- Diets
or supplements excessively high in tea
(or tannic acid), protein, calcium,
phosphorus or fiber can interfere with
iron absorption.
ZINC
Zinc is a
trace mineral which is important for the health
of the skin and perhaps the lining of the
arteries. Veterinarians found that animals whose
feed contained inadequate amounts of zinc
developed red and cracked skin with loss of hair
or wool, as well as other problems. In humans,
zinc supplementation is a well-documented,
effective treatment for acne.
Zinc is
found in dramatically high concentrations in the
prostate gland and semen, and we now know that
adequate levels of zinc are required for the
proper functioning of the sexual organs of the
male. Zinc deficiencies have also been found in
children who had a history of poor appetite and
failure to gain in height and weight. One of the
symptoms noticed among boys in one study was a
loss of sense of taste. Loss of taste is
important, since it tends to decrease appetite
and the enjoyment of food, and this leads to
further malnutrition and failure to grow
properly. In every case, the sense of taste was
restored by taking zinc, and other health
improvements were dramatic.
Meat,
poultry and fish are by far the richest sources
of zinc. Although some vegetable foods contain
substantial amounts of it, fibre and phytates
appear to carry much of it out of the body.
Phytates are phosphorus compounds found in most
plant foods but especially in whole grains,
beans, and peas. They have the property of
combining with minerals, especially calcium,
iron, and zinc, to form insoluble compounds which
are carried out in the stool. Though other
minerals are well absorbed from plant foods,
zinclike iron or calciumseems more
problematic, and nutritionists have expressed
concern over the availability of zinc in the
vegetarian diet.
There are
recent research studies that indicate this
concern may well be justified. For example, when
a group of students were put on a vegetarian diet
for three weeks, their tissue levels of zinc
dropped and they responded to physiological tests
in a way that suggested they had developed a mild
zinc deficiency.
But three
weeks isn't long. As mentioned, we know that in
the case of other minerals such as calcium, some
adaptation to the presence of fibre and phytates
occurs and that, over time, absorption improves.
So the research team looked next at a group of 79
persons that had been vegetarian for a year or
longer. They found that their body levels of zinc
were also low,- despite the fact that they had
been vegetarian for a longer period of time.
This is
different from other minerals, where adaptation
seems to take place and phytates and fibre seem
to lose their tendency to interfere with mineral
absorption. Why would zinc be different? The
answer may lie in the fact that the enzyme that
is developed to break down
phytatesintestinal phytaseis itself
zinc dependent. Zinc is needed for the
manufacture of phytase, and when zinc is
deficient the enzyme cannot be produced in
adequate amounts. So a vicious circle ensues:
less phytase means more phytate to interfere with
the absorption of zinc, which in turn results in
more severe zinc depletion and still less
phytase.
Therefore,
once a zinc deficiency is established, it would
appear that it would be difficult to climb out of
iteven with adequate zinc intake was long
as one's diet is rich in whole grains, which
contain so much phytic acid. Once phytase
production has been started, and zinc can be
released from phytate and absorbed, handling a
vegetarian diet is possible. But if a person's
zinc stores are depleted during the transition
phase, he won't be able to increase his output of
phytase and adjust to the new diet. For such
reasons, zinc supplements may be necessary during
the time when one is changing over to a
vegetarian diet.
Though the
transition period is always tricky and is a time
when developing a zinc deficiency is especially
likely, this risk is even higher if one starts
out with a borderline zinc deficiency. There is
evidence, such as low zinc levels in patients
with retarded wound-healing, indicating that a
significant percentage of the general,
non-vegetarian population suffers from marginal
zinc status. Girls and young women seem to have
substandard intakes most often, though men and
boys, who tend to eat more animal foods, may
become deficient despite their larger intakes
since the normal development and functioning of
the male reproductive system requires a
substantial intake of zinc. This is thought to be
why it is mostly boys who have been found to be
undersize as a result of zinc deficiency. In
adult males, zinc deficiency can contribute to
sterility and impotence.
Zinc
nutrition for pregnant and nursing women is of
serious concern, since the infant must draw its
supply of zinc from the mother. Materrial zinc
deprivation in experimental animals has produced
offspring with learning disabilities and
abnormalities in the chemistry and structure of
the brain, especially that part that is related
to emotions. (In view of this it is interesting
that some cases of schizophrenia seem to clear
dramatically when given zinc.) There is also
evidence that zinc deficiency during pregnancy
can lead to later impairment of immune function.
Low zinc
later in life may also lead to a number of
symptoms of immune deficiency as well as
impairment of the capacity to heal quickly.
Inadequate tissue repair has been suspected of
playing a role in the earliest stages of the
development of atherosclerosis, where failure to
properly heal some form of injury to the arterial
lining may set the stage for plaque formation.
Getting
Enough Zinc
If one does
decide to take zinc supplements while adjusting
to a vegetarian diet, 15 to 20 milligrams a day
should be sufficient, since the recommended daily
intake is only 15. Since absorption is only
partial on any diet, this amount would not be
excessive, especially when fibre and phytate
levels are substantial.
In fact,
zinc is one of the nutrients with the largest
margin of safety. One would have to take vvell
over 100 milligrams a day to cause any toxicity.
Unfortunately, some physicians and laypersons
recommend 135 milligrams per day for treatment of
acne, much higher than what is necessary or
desirable.
Even at
moderate doses zinc can compete with copper for
absorption or utilization. Since vegetarian diets
tend to be relatively rich in copper, this is not
likely to be a problem. However, zinc can also
interfere with selenium utilization, and though
selenium, too, is generally ample in vegetarian
diets, zinc doses should be kept at reasonable
levels for this reason.
Zinc
Checklist
- Keep fiber
intake moderate.
- Include tofu,
beans, seeds, and nuts in your
diet.
- Watch for
signs of zinc deficiency: white
spots on
nails, slow wound healing, poor
resistance to
infections, acne.
- Consider
supplementation-especially during
transition phase.
|
Besides milk and eggs, the
non-meat foods richest in zinc are beans, tofu,
seeds, nuts, and hard cheeses. If these foods are
taken in the diet and the fibre intake is kept
moderate, zinc should not be a problem. Those in
transition, and pregnant or nursing women should
consider supplementation. Because of its role in
the sense of taste, it is a happy coincidence
that those in need of zinc generally find its
taste agreeable, and those who have adequate
levels find the taste unpleasant. This has led to
a simple taste test for deficiency. Other signs
of zinc deficiency are: white spots on nails,
slow wound healing, poor resistance to infections
and acne.
Vitamin
B12
Vitamin Bl2
is unique in many ways. First of all, it is the
vitamin which is needed by the body in the
tiniest amounts. Only a few thousands of a
milligram (3 or 4 micrograms) per day are
necessary to prevent the symptoms of deficiency.
Even more important for vegetarians is the fact
that vitamin Bl2 is the only vitamin
which is not found in strictly vegetarian diets,
e.g. those without dairy products. Vitamin Bl2 is
present in milk, eggs, and meat, and is
manufactured by many bacteria and yeasts. Any
food which is strictly of plant origin, not
ferrnented, and free of all bacteria and insects,
will be found to contain no vitamin Bl2
In cultures
where food is grown organically and processed
little or not at all, deficiencies of vitamin Bl2
are uncommon, even when there is no meat, milk,
eggs or other animal food in the diet. This is
thought to be due to the fact that organically
grown foods will often contain traces of bacteria
from the soil or even tiny bits of insects which
are difficult to see or remove completely. These
alone may be enough to provide the extremely
small doses of vitamin Bl2that are
necessary. When foods are grown with the use of
pesticides, however, insects and bacteria are
likely to have been thoroughly exterminated, and
the processing of food to make it suitable for
long storage or shelf-life will be even more
likely to remove any traces of vitamin Bl2.
Thus vegans who eat processed foods are at
increased risk.
It is often
said that a vegetarian diet can supply everything
except vitamin Bl2. Physicians and
nutritionists are trained to caution those who
are eliminating all animal foods about the grave
consequences of Bl2 deficiency and to
advise them that, at the very least, Bl2
supplements should be taken. This concern is
understandable. Pernicious anemia, the disease
connected with insufficient body stores of
vitamin Bl2, is a serious disease.
In the
early stages of the illness there are numbness
and tingling of the hands and feet with a loss of
sensation. Blood tests done on such patients
reveal low hemoglobin levels and large, pale, red
bloods cells. Gradually a lack of motor
coordination develops. These symptoms are now
known to be due to an in ability to synthesize
myelin, the fatty sheath that insulates nerve
fibres. As a result, the nerves to the limbs
degenerate. If allowed to proceed unchecked, the
deterioration progresses into the spinal cord and
ultimately to the brain. Moodiness, poor memory,
and confusion give way gradually to delusions,
hallucinations, and overt psychosis. For vitamin
Bl2to be absorbed, the stomach wall
must secrete a substance called intrinsic factor,
which combines with the Bl2, forming a
complex that can then be taken up by the lower
end of the small intestine. Patients with
pernicious anemia were found to lack intrinsic
factor because of the destruction of stomach wall
cells. Thus Bl2, even when present in
the diet in ample quantities, cannot be absorbed.
When
originally described, the disease was observed to
occur sporadically in most populations without
regard to dietary practices. It was not
considered to result from inadequate dietary
intake of vitamin Bl2. Indeed there
was no reason to assume that the disease had
anything to do with the amount of vitamin Bl2
consumed, since amounts many times than
ordinarily needed are of no use without intrinsic
factor.
Nevertheless,
because it has long been known that vitamin Bl2
is absent from foods that are strictly of plant
origin, when nutritionists and dieticians began
to encounter growing numbers of strict
vegetarians, they were alarmed. While vegetarians
who used dairy products were generally thought to
be on safe ground, vegans, who take no foods of
animal origin, were a different matter. A diet
with no Bl2) it was felt, was sure to
produce vitamin Bl2 deficiency and
ultimately pernicious anemia.
Dietary
Deficiency of Bl2:
Myth or Reality ?
In the
1960s and 1970s a large number of case reports in
medical journals seemed to fulfill this dire
prophecy: "Subacute combined degeneration of
the spinal cord in a vegan",
"Megaloblastic anemia in an adult
vegan," and so on. Nutrition manuals warned
of the danger of developing pernicious anemia
from an inadequate intake of vitamin Bl2.
But despite the ominous tone of such case
reports, surveys of groups of vegans reported
with some surprise that most of the subjects they
studied seemed quite well, with no signs of
anemia or neurological degeneration. The
occurrence of symptoms was, at most, rare. one
might expect, after all, to find some cases of
the disease in any population.
Were the
cases of pernicious anemia that were reported
merely persons with the disease who happened to
be vegans, or were these cases caused by the
all-plant diet? Of course, vegans argued the
former in their magazines and newsletters, while
nutritionists argued the latter in their books
and scientific journals. As is usual with such
debates, the ardour of the controversy yielded
little in the way of illumination.
Nevertheless,
by the beginning of the 1980s there was enough
published literature to make evident some of the
oversights that had led to premature conclusions:
many of the diagnoses of inadequate vitamin Bl2
in the diet had been hastily made. For example,
problems that can interfere with absorption, such
as a lack of intrinsic factor, had not been ruled
out as causes of the low body level of Bl2.
To establish firmly that a person is suffering
from a dietary deficiency of vitamin Bl2,
certain criteria must be met.
A critical
review of reports published up to 1980 on vegans
showed that none of them met all these criteria.
In each case, other explanations were possible,
including deficiency of intrinsic factor, iron
deficiency anemia, and neurological problems from
other causes. In fact, in many of the published
case reports, the authors noted that these
alternative explanations seemed the most likely.
Yet the cumulative weight of the first
impressions created by numbers of such scientific
papers is persuasive in itself and has tended to
support the view not only that dietary deficiency
of vitamin Bl2 is an actuality, but
that it is common among vegetarians who use no
animal foods. Despite this prevailing impression,
in point of fact there is little incontrovertible
evidence that a diet low in Bl2 can,
in and of itself, cause problems.
Vitamin
B12 Vegan Sources
If it's
true that a purely dietary deficiency of Bl2
occurs rarely, if at all, the question is,
Why? How could it be that vegans, who
consistently consume no BI2-containing
foods at all, might be perfectly healthy, with
adequate tissue levels of the vitamin?
At least
part of the answer to this question becomes
apparent when we look at the origin of vitamin Bl2.
Though it is found in animal foods, it is not
manufactured by animal cells. It must be absorbed
from their food by most animals, as it must be by
humans. All Bl2 is made by bacteria.
Ruminants, such as cows, do quite well, because
bacteria in an accessory stomach, or rumen,
produce Bl2 as they break down the
fibre of the animal's food. But bacteria aren't
just in cows' stomachs; they're practically
everywhere. Researchers studying B12
have complained that it is necessary to carefully
clean all instruments to get meaningful
measurements of Bl2 -since even tap water can
contain substantial amounts. ("Substantial
amounts" in the sense that they can approach
the range of what is needed in the human diet.)
It is for
this reason that some batches of beans, bean
sprouts, comfrey leaves, turnip greens, peanuts,
lettuce, fermented soybeans, and whole wheat have
been reported to contain significant amounts of Bl2while
other batches of the same foods have been found
to have none at all. The presence of bacteria on
such foods is incidental; that is, the presence
or absence of the vitamin will depend on whether
the plants were fertilized with manure or not,
how well they were washed and with what, and so
forth. So as sources of Bl2 any one of
such foods must be considered unreliable, though
on any average day several of them might happen
to bring along some small but significant amounts
of the vitamin.
What's
more, bacteria also grow on and in the body. In
fact, it has been estimated that the
microorganisms between the teeth and gums, around
and in the crevices of the tonsils, in the folds
at the base of the tongue, and in the upper
respiratory passages will make up to half a
microgram of B12 a day. This is at
least half of the minimum requirement, though
some nutritionists think this quantity may be all
that is needed for most people. Official
recommended intakes by the World Health
Organization and the Food and Nutrition Board
provide for generous margins of safety, and up
the level to as high as 3 or 4 micrograms for
adults, but it is unlikely that it is necessary
or even useful to consume such large amounts. An
egg or a cup of milk will contain 1 microgram of
vitamin Bl2 (see table below).
B12
Content of Common Foods
| Food |
Amount |
B12(mcg) |
| Organ
meats(e.g., liver) |
3 oz |
>10 |
| Bivalves
(clams, oysters) |
3 oz |
>10 |
| Milk
|
1 cup |
1 |
| Fish |
3 oz |
1-3 |
| Beef |
3 oz |
1-3 |
| Chicken |
3 oz |
1-3 |
| Cheese,hard |
1 oz |
0.3 |
| Egg
yolk |
1 |
1 |
| Fermented soy
products: |
| Miso |
1 T |
c. 0.03 (variable) |
| Tempeh |
3 oz |
c.3 (variable) |
| Seaweed |
- |
variable |
| Spirulina |
- |
variable |
| Yogurt |
1 c |
0.3 |
* See p. 168
Sources :
Goodman and Gillman : Pharmacological Basis of
Therapeutics. U.S Dept. of Agriculture : Vitamin
B12 in Foods. Shurtleff : Sources of B12
Other
Complications in Vitamin B12
absorption
There are
countless bacteria in the human intestinal tract,
too. Whether or not they make a contribution to
the Bl2 needs of their human host is
the subject of another long-standing controversy.
Early studies on the bacterial flora of the gut
focused on the colon, where the bulk of the
intestinal microorganisms are found. Although
producers of Bl2 were found there,
there was a controversy around whether this would
pass through the wall of the large intestine.
More refined research techniques revealed that a
smaller but still substantial community of
bacteria inhabits the small intestine. Recent
studies have demonstrated that these organisms do
produce vitamin Bl2 and that they do
so high enough in the intestinal tract to allow
it to combine with intrinsic factor before it
reaches the lower end of the small intestine,
where the vitamin is absorbed.
Another
complication is that some bacteria will compete
with their host for dietary B12
without contributing significant quantities in
return. They can even deplete body stores, since
Bl2 is constantly being secreted with the bile.
Ordinarily much of this Bl2 is
reabsorbed as the bile passes through the
intestinal tract; but occasionally an unfriendly
population of bacteria with an inclination for
robbing their host of vitamins will prevent
reabsorption. It's also known that B12
absorption is more thorough when intake is lower.
In other words, the meat-eater who consumes 10
micrograms of vitamin Bl2 in a day
will absorb only 16% of it, while the vegan who
takes in a mere fraction of that will absorb 70%.
All of these factors add up to a rather delicate
balance, which can be disturbed by any major
disruption, such as migration to a different
culture, or the use of antibiotic medications.
Other important factors:
- Excess
fat or protein. Too much in the diet can
increase vitamin Bl2 needs.
- Highly
processed foods. Whereas boiling milk for
two to five minutes only decreased its
B12 content by 30%, sterilization in
sealed containers for 13 minutes caused a
loss of 77%. Canned milk, for example,
might be an inadequate source of vitamin
Bl2.
- Drugs,
Tobacco, coffee, alcohol, and birth
control pills have all been implicated in
increasing one's need for B12.
- Pregnancy
and nursing. Both pregnancy and nursing
increase needs for vitamin Bl2.
Low intake during nursing, for example,
has resulted in breastmilk that is
deficient even when the mother's levels
remain normal, and has also resulted in
symptoms such as apathy and retardation
in the infant.
- Chronic
disease. Intestinal parasites, malaria,
liver disease, chronic infections, and
cancer will all disrupt normal mechanisms
of Bl2 absorption and use, and
increase needs.
- Intestinal
surgery. Removal of part of the stomach,
where intrinsic factor is made and
secreted, or removal of part of the lower
small intestine, where it is absorbed,
can drastically reduce uptake and may
necessitate the use of injectable Bl2.
- Use of
megadoses of vitamin C, multiple
vitamin/mineral preparations containing
copper, and perhaps other food
supplements such as spirulina (see
below).
Vitamin
B12, Mega C, and other supplements
Another
ongoing controversy is that surrounding the
effects of large doses of vitamin C on Bl2
availability. In 1974, one of the most respected
authorities on vitamin Bl2 reported
that mixing vitaniin C with vitamin Bl2
and incubating the combination in a way that
would mimic digestion destroyed B12.
Both the population news media and the medical
literature were quickly filled with warnings
about the danger of vitamin C. Two years later,
however, a different author observed that the
original had been done using methods of B12
measurement that were designed to test blood, not
food. Since the B12 in food is more
tightly bound to protiens he concluded that the
tests used had failed to pick it up. Using more
apporopriate techniques, no destruction of B12
was found. The researcher who had done the first
study retaliated in 1978, demonstrating low blood
levels of vitamin B12 in patients who
took 2 grams of vitamin C in a day and noting
that another study had reported similar results.
Although
the issue is still not completely resolved, it
would appear that anyone taking more than 500
milligrams of vitamin C a day for a long period
of time should have his or her vitamin Bl2
status monitored. An alternative that might
provide some protection is to take vitamin C in
high doses only for short periods of time,
allowing intervals when it is stopped so that Bl2
stores can be replenished. A convenient regimen
is one week on and one week off.
Other
nutritional supplements can cause trouble, too.
It is well established that vitamin Bl2
is destroyed by oxygen in the presence of vitamin
C, vitamin B. (thiarnine), and copper ions. This
may affect the Bl2 present in
multivitamin preparations. It has been reported
that 20% to 90% of the vitamin present in such
supplements can be degraded to vitamin B1,
analogues.
What
to Do About Bl2.
- If you use
substantial amnounts of fish,
milk,
or eggs, you will have an extra
margin of safety. If not:
- Dont smoke,
drink coffee, use alcohol
regularly, or take
birth control pills.
- Beware of the
use of Antibiotics or
contaminated meat,
poultry, or fish that can create
havoc in the microbial
population of the intestinal
tract.
- If you
devolop an illness, especially a
chronic one, pay
perticular attention to your Bl2
intake, or better yet, find
a physician knowledgeable about
nutrition to help.
|
These are Bl2-like
molecules that are similar enough to the real
thing to replace it in metabolic reactions, but
different enough to lack the effectiveness of the
vitamin. Some of them can thus block the activity
of the Bl2 that is present, preventing
it from being used normally.
Spirulina, a dietary
supplement widely acclaimed as an extraordinary
source of Bl2, has also been found to
contain many more Bl2 analogues than
genuine Bl2five to eight times
as many. Whether or not these analogues are Bl2
antagonists and cause harm awaits investigation.
Bl2
as an oral supplement, when taken separately from
other nutrients that can degrade it, such as
vitamin C, copper, and thiamine, can be of help,
however. It can be used by those with inadequate
dietary Bl2 or when illness may
increase one's needs beyond what is a normally
adequate dietary intake. It can even be effective
in those cases where absorption is impaired by a
lack of intrinsic factor, since somewhere between
1% and 3% of vitamin Bl2 passes across
the intestinal wall by simple diffusion. But much
higher doses must be used when the normal
mechanisms of fictive uptake are missing.
Nutritional
yeast is sometimes used as a dietary supplement
to supply vitamin Bl2 by those who are
consuming only vegetable foods. Not all
nutritional or brewer's yeast, however, will
furnish the vitamin. In order to contain Bl2,
the medium on which such yeast is grown must
contain it or it must be added during the final
processing. If one wishes to use yeast as a
source, one must read labels carefully to be sure
that the yeast in question does indeed contain
the vitamin, and in adequate amounts (at least 1
microgram in 1 tablespoon, since a tablespoonful
is a maximal appropriate regular daily dose of
yeast).
Thus
with a little bit of care, vegetarians can have
the best of both worldsthey can be certain
of adequate nutrition, and avoid the
atherosclerosis and cancer so common among
meateaters. In addition, the transition to
vegetarianism entails a transformation of
consciousness as well.
The
resources expended by those who are eating in a
self-destructive way are not available for higher
purposes such as creativity, self-development,
and the exploration of the inner world. For us to
progress to a new stage of development we must
carefully examine our way of living and divest
ourselves of those habits that are most limiting.
A vegetarian diet which skilfillly includes all
the necessary nutrients for human function
appears more and more to be an evolutionary step
that is inevitable.
REFERENCES
- Monsen
E.R. , Hallberg L., Layrisse M., etal:
Estimation of available dietary iron.
American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,
1978, 31: 134-41.
- Cook
J.D. . Noble N.L., Morsk T.A., et al:
Effect of fibre on non-heme iron
absorption. Gastroenterology, 1983, 85:
1354-58.
- Walker
A.R.P., Walker B.F.: Effect of wholemeal
and white bread on iron absorption.
British Medical Journal 19Z7, 2: 771-2.
- Michaelsson,
G. et al.: Effects of oral zinc and
vitamin A in acne. Journal of the
American Medical Association, 1977, 237:
401.
- Prasad
A .: Zinc deficiency in man. American
Journal of Diseases of the Child. 1976,
130: 357-361.
- Freeland-Graves
J.H., Bodzy P. W., Eppright M.A.: Zinc
status of vegetarians. Journal of the
American Dietetic Association, 1980, 77:
655-61.
- Sandstead
H.H.: Zinc nutntion in the United States.
American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,
1973, 26: 151-60.
- Patterson
K.Y., Holbrook J.T., Bodner J.E., et.
al.: Zinc, copper, and manganese intake
and balance for adults consuming
self-selected diets. American Journal of
Clinical Nutrition, 1984, 50s: 1397-1403.
- Underwood
E.J.: Trace Elements in Human and Animal
Nutrition, 4th ed., New York: Academic
Press, 1977, pp. 219-20.
- Sandstead
H.H., Evans G. W.: Zinc, in Present
Knowledge in Nutrition, pp. 479-505.
- Jathar
V.S., Inamdar-Deshmukh A.B., Rege D.V.,
Satoskar R.S.: Vitamm Bl2 and
Vegetarianism in India. Acta
Haemotologia, 1975, 53: 90-97.
- Ellis
F.R., Montegriffo V.M.E.: Veganism:
Clinical findings and investigations.
American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,
1970, 23: 249-55.
- Albert
M.J., Mathan V.I., Baker S. T.: Vitatnin
Bl2 synthesis by human small
intestine bacteria. Nature, 1980, 283:
781-82.
- Siddens
R.C.: The experimental production of
vitamin Bl2 deficiency in the
baboon (Papio cynocephalus), a 2-year
study. British Journat of Nutrition,
1974, 32: 219-28.
- Herbert
V., Jacob E.: Destruction of vitamin Bl2
by ascorbic acid. Journal of the American
Medical Association, 1974, 230: 241-42.
- Herbert
V., Jacob E., Wong K., et. al.: Low serum
vitamin Bl2 levels in patients
receiving ascorbic acid in megadoses:
Studies concerning the effect of
ascorbate on radioisotope vitamin Bl2
assay. American Journal of Clinic
Nutrition, 1978, 31: 253-58.
|