. |
Medicine
and Books Amoebic
Liver Abscess. O P Kapoor (Pp 205; Rs.425) S S
Publishers, 1979
Parasitological
surveys have shown that about 3% to 5% of the population
of the UK are asymptomatic carriers of Entamoeba
histolytica, and that about 200 cases of clinical
amoebiasis are diagnosed in England and Wales each year.
Many cases probably go unrecognized including a few which
the reach the necropsy room. Because the disease is
comparatively rare in Western Europe, it is often not
considered by clinicians in this list of differential
diagnoses; likewise, research for the elusive amoeba in
stool is made by laboratory staff with little experience
of this particular parasite.
Hepatic amoebiasis is one important form of the disease,
and Dr. Kapoors book is based on his personal
experience of 200 cases seen in Bombay. In a historical
review he tell us of the officer in 1818 who was cured of
his liver abscess when it was opened by a fortuitously
well placed shot, and he also makes a case for amoebiasis
as the cause of Napoleons death. Subsequent
chapters discuss the world distribution of the disease,
the mechanisms by which the scanty population of amoebae
in the liver may cause such extensive damage, and the
immunological response to the invader. New understanding
has grown from studies of animal models.
The clinical sections of these monographs are
particularly clearly presented and illustrated. The
cardinal symptoms are upper abdominal pain and fever, but
both may be absent and Dr. Kapoor emphasizes the
importance of recognizing the rarer pulmonary and cardiac
presentations. Most abscesses occur in the right lobe,
but those in the left lobe present with a more variable
clinical picture and may perforate into the pericardium
or general peritoneal cavity, thereby creating an acute
surgical emergency. The patient may thus present to one
of a number of different specialists. Usually the most
prominent physical sign is a tender enlargement of the
liver. A focal point of tenderness is a valuable sign and
indicates the best sport to aspirate the abscess. A few
patients with large of multiple amoebic abscesses may
have jaundice or portal systemic encephalopathy.
Special
investigations
Hepatic scintiscanning with 99mTc sulphur
colloid is emphasized as an important step in diagnosing
and localising the abscess and scanning agents excreted
in the biliary tree such as 131I Rose Bengal -
will often help to distinguish an abscess near the gall
bladder bed from an empyema. Ultrasound, which has only
recently become available to the author in Bombay,
receives little mention. In skilled hands this is
probably as good as or better than scintiscanning at
localizing an abscess and, unlike the latter, it has the
advantage of usually being able to differentiate an
abscess from a liver tumour - another common cause of
fever and hepatic enlargement in tropical areas.
Ultrasound will clearly become more widely available in
developing countries and portable machines are being made
for use in rural areas. The role of abdominal
computerised axial tomography is not defined. The various
available serological tests are discussed; while they
remain positive for some years after an amoebic
infection, a negative result is distinctly unusual in a
patient with an amoebic liver abscess.
Management
The medical management is well described. The author
favours a combination of two drugs - usually
dehydroemetine, and either metronidazole or chloroquine.
The former is favoured when there is a coexistent
dysentery. The most important point in evaluating the
clinical response is relief of pain, which should be
almost complete in four or five days. Controversy
continues about the advisability of aspirating amoebic
liver abscesses. Dr. Kapoor recommends aspiration of very
large or superficial abscesses, those causing sever pain
in rupture may be imminent, and left-lobe abscesses. The
procedure is clearly described. Despite the hallowed
textbook descriptions, the pus removed is seldom like
anchovy sauce but usually more chocolate coloured and, on
occasion, it may be creamy yellow. Surgical intervention
is rarely necessary unless the abscess develops secondary
bacterial infection or rupture occurs.
This is a readable and lavishly illustrated book and,
while most the illustration are of high standard the
reproduction of the few photomicrographs and some of the
radiographs is disappointing. The bibliography is
extensive and up to date. The book can be recommended to
all doctors who see patients with amoebiasis and, because
of increasing air travel, we should all be alert to this
diagnostic possibility.
IAIN
M MURRAY-LYON
The Lancet, March
29 1980
Amoebic Liver Abscess
O. P. KAPOOR, Grant Medical College, Bombay
Bombay: S. S. Publishers. 1979. Pp. 208. $ 50 Rs 425
HEPATIC amoebic
abscess, although a rare clinical problem in the United
Kingdom, should always be borne in mind since the
diagnosis may well be missed in sporadic cases. This
monograph, embodying the author's personal experience of
many hundreds of patients with amoebic abscess of the
liver, should be a useful reference book The emphasis is
clinical, the book consisting largely of descriptions of
the syndromes produced by an abscess in different parts
of the liver and the special problem of pulmonary amoebic
abscess. To allocate a whole chapter to a description of
the pus from an amoebic abscess may seem excessive, but
it is an example of the author's careful observation that
typifies this book. The historical review and chapters on
pathogenesis, pathology, and immunology are brief but, as
in all the sections, the literature is well reviewed. The
investigation of a suspected amoebic abscess is described
clearly and includes chapters on the role of serology,
radiology, hepatic scintigraphy, ultrasonic imaging, and
CAT scanning. The differential diagnosis and atypical
presentations are discussed in several short chapters.
The sections on medical and surgical treatment of the
condition will be useful to those with limited experience
in this area; the stages of medical treatment and
indications for aspiration and surgical treatment are
clearly stated. The outstanding feature of this book is
the very high standard of illustrations consisting of two
hundred excellent colour photographs and clear
reproduction of radiographs. The author has a
conversational style of writing which makes the book easy
to read. This book should prove a useful reference volume
in any medical library.
|