. |
An
amoebic liver abscess can have a variety of clinical
presentations. In this chapter, the general
well-recognised clinical features of amoebic liver
abscess are discussed.
Age
Although an amoebic liver abscess can develop at any
age, it is more frequently encountered in adult life with
the highest incidence occurring in the third, fourth and
fifth decades. The disease is rare at the two extremes of
life. The age-wise distribution of this disease noted by
various observers is presented in Table I.
Table I
From the above
date, it is obvious that 75-90% of the total cases occur
between the ages 21 and 50. Below 20 years of age, the
incidence is less than 7% and above the age of 50, it is
less than 21% . It must, therefore, be noted that no age
is exempt and cases have been encountered in infants4,5 as well as in elderly
individuals.
Sex
Amoebic liver abscess is far more common in males
than in females. About 85-95% of the total cases seem to
occur in males. This higher incidence in males is still
unexplained. Since there is a higher incidence of
intestinal amoebiasis in males, one would also expect to
find a higher incidence of amoebic liver abscess in them.
However, even after allowing for this factor, the
incidence in females remains much lower! The sex
incidence of this disease is shown in Table II.
Table II
Race
Earlier workers11 noticed that the incidence
of amoebic liver abscess was lower in the native
population of the tropics as compared to that in the
resident whites. This, still, has not been substantiated
by later workers.
Diarrhoea and dysentery
About 40% patients with liver abscess complain of
diarrhoea while only 10% suffer from amoebic dysentery
with trophozoites present in the stool. Roughly, 50% give
a previous history of dysentery. But there is a wide
variation in the reported series.
Craig12 has enumerated the findings
of various authors. He states that 60-90% give a previous
history of dysentery or attacks of severe diarrhoea. In
our series of 200 cases, in 60% a past history of
diarrhoea was elicited whereas only 30% gave a past
history of dysentery.
However, hepatic complications have been reported in
individuals who have never had dysentery before.1 If there is a history of an
European patient having been to an endemic areas or an
American soldier to a tropical region, even as much as 20
to 30 years earlier, the diagnosis of amoebic liver
abscess should still be considered.13
Alcohol
Ochsner and DeBakey14 attribute higher incidence
in males to alcoholism, which predisposes to hepatitis
and trauma. Very few workers have tried to confirm the
actual relationship of alcohol to amoebic liver abscess.
Alcohol is commonly believed to play some role in the
etiology of amoebic liver abscess and many patients give
a past history of consuming it. According to some authors
the incidence varies from 20%15 - 62.5%16,17. In our series the
incidence was 60%. Klatskin18, Rajasuriya19 and Ramachandran17 have tried to go into more
details regarding the amount and the type of alcohol
consumed and the duration of the addiction. According to
Anderson,20 the consensus of opinion,
however, supports the contention that alcoholism
predisposes to amoebic abscess.
Other predisposing factors
In my experience, I have seen a dozen patients who
have had an attack of typical viral hepatitis just
preceding an illness of amoebic liver abscess. I cannot
interpret the relationship between the two illnesses.
According to Carig12, other predisposing factors
are exposure, improper diet, mental anxiety and worry.
Trauma over the hepatic area may lead to lowered
resistance to infection. Unaccustomed physical exertion
and sudden violent movements of the chest have been noted
to precede the onset of clinical manifestations of
amoebic liver abscess.21 History of having consumed
steroids must be enquired into, since this drug may
provoke a fulminating progression of hepatic amoebiasis.22
Onset of disease
Most authorities agree that the patients may present
with acute onset of less than a weeks duration or
the illness may have had an insidious onset, spread over
several months. Thus, in practice one sees three types of
onset - (1) acute, (2) subacute and (3) chronic. In our
series of 200 cases, 40% patients presented with an acute
onset and 10% with a chronic onset of few months
duration. The majority (50%) presented with the subacute
type of onset of a few weeks duration. The findings
of other authors are presented in Table III.
TABLE III
From the above
table it is apparent that the majority of patients have a
subacute onset.
It should be remembered that the duration of the history,
however, has little clinical significance and is not
reliable indicator of the prognosis.
SYMPTOMS OF AMOEBIC
LIVER ABSCESS
Majority of the patients present with pain and
fever. Few cases are asymptomatic and are discovered only
when complications occur. DeBakey and Jordan24 classified the symptoms as
local and systemic.
Table IV
demonstrated the frequency of various symptoms in order
of frequency are fever with or without chills, rigors or
night sweats, weakness, diarrhoea or dysentery, anorexia,
nausea or vomiting, etc.
TABLE IV
SYSTEMIC SYMPTOMS
FEVER
The incidence of
fever varies from 46-95%. Sometimes, however, fever may
be entirely absent. The fever may be continuous or
intermittent and may be accompanied by rigors.23,30 According to Wilmot25 rigors are distinctly
uncommon. In our experience chills are frequent in the
beginning of the illness only. In amoebic liver abscess
of acute onset, the temperature is often high and of a
remittent variety accompanied by profuse perspiration. In
the chronic forms the fever is often low, develops more
gradually and may be the only symptom for weeks. In such
cases sweating is less pronounced and chills may not
occur.
Acute cases with high fever and right basal pulmonary
signs may be wrongly diagnosed as right basal pneumonia.
Cases in which the fever lasts for several weeks may
often be misdiagnosed as enteric fever or tuberculosis.
Madangopalan29 found that 0.7% cases of
P.U.O. had amoebic liver abscess.
OTHER SYSTEMIC SYMPTOMS
Weakness may appear early in amoebic liver
abscess but is very prominent in advanced cases. A
feeling of lassitude and fatigue may be present in
subacute and chronic forms of the disease. Other symptoms
like weight loss are always present, particularly if the
duration of illness is more than two weeks.9 Where the illness extends
over several months, the weight loss may exceed one-third
of the lean body-mass so that these cases are often
misdiagnosed as carcinoma of the liver.29 Weight loss is found to
occur in 10-50% of the patients in various series.
Cough is another common symptom. It is usually dry and
unproductive. Amoebic liver abscess with basal pulmonary
signs may also given rise to breathlessness.20 Sometimes patients suffer
from hiccough.
Other symptoms which may occur in a small number of
patients are anorexia, nausea, vomiting and oedema feet.
Sometimes the latter is associated with a distended
abdomen due to ascites.
Mild jaundice may be present in a few patients. Deep
jaundice of the obstructive type may rarely be the
presenting symptom.23
LOCAL SYMPTOMS
PAIN
The earliest and most common local symptom of
amoebic liver abscess is pain. It is present in 65% to
almost 100% cases (Table IV).
Character of pain. In uncomplicated amoebic liver abscess
it may start as a dull ache or a feeling of heaviness and
become sharp and stabbing later on. Pain may increase by
change in position, deep breathing or coughing. Alcohol
is also known to aggravate it.30 The pain may become worse
at night. Inactivity and turning to the opposite side
relieves the pain. The latter is probably due to the
release of tension on the liver capsule by opening up of
the intercostal spaces.
Site and radiation of pain. The most common site of pain
is the right hypochondrium and the right lower chest
anteriorly.
Localisation of the pain will depend upon which surface
and the lobe of the liver is the abscess located. Right
lobe abscess will produce pain the right lower chest
anteriorly or posteriorly. Pain may be felt in right
hypochondrium, right subcostal area or in the area of the
gall bladder.
A patient having an abscess beneath the right dome of the
diaphragm will complain of pain over the tip of the right
shoulder.25 Sometimes, there is only a
soreness of the right shoulder. Occasionally pain may be
referred to the right side of the neck. A right lobe
abscess may also present with pain in the right flank,
right loin or in the right scapular region in the back.
In amoebic liver abscess complicated by pleuropulmonary
syndrome, pain may be felt over part or whole of the
right hemithorax.
In amoebic abscess of the left lobe, pain is felt in the
epigastrium and left hypochondrium. It may radiate to the
left back, the left loin and the scapular region. A
rupture of the left lobe abscess into left hemithorax may
produce pain the left hemithorax. When it ruptures into
the pericardial sac, pain may be precordial or
restrosternal in location. Rupture into the peritoneal
cavity may result in severe generalised pain of an
acute abdomen. Less commonly, a liver abscess may
leak into the peritoneal cavity along the right paracolic
gutter and form walled-off abscesses, which may give rise
to localised pain in the right illiac fossa. Rarely,
chronic peritonitis with adhesions and loculated
collection of pus may cause vague upper abdominal pain.
Amoebic abscess occurring in patients with dextro-cardia
with transposition of viscera will cause pain in the
opposite hemithorax. Two such case reports have been
published till now.33,34
SIGNS of AMOEBIC
LIVER ABSCESS
Local signs
Hepatomegaly
The most important physical sign in amoebic
liver abscess is a tender, enlarged liver. Its incidence
in various clinical series is presented in Table V.
TABLE V
The enlargement
varies with the site and size of the abscess. With large
abscesses the liver may extend into the umbilicus. There
may be (i) generalised enlargement of the liver, (ii)
enlargement of the right lobe only, (iii) enlargement of
the left lobe only, (iv) only upward enlargement of the
right or left lobe (this is diagnosed by percussing the
upper border of the liver: Quite often in patients with
this type of enlargement, an auscultation there is
diminished air entry at the right base), (v) enlargement
in the horizontal plane towards the left hypochondrium
(usually in a left lobe amoebic liver abscess), (vi)
posterior enlargement, or (vii) rarely no enlargement at
all.
The edge is usually ill-defined, rounded and soft. Often
the edge is difficult to feel because of localised
rigidity and guarding in the right hypochondrium. Rarely
compensatory hypertrophy of the liver in the area around
a large abscess cavity may lead to a certain amount of
irregularity and even nodularity making differentiation
from malignancy of the liver difficult.
Local liver enlargement in the form of a mass or a lump
may sometimes be seen in the right hypochondrium or
epigastrium. Its surface can be smooth or irregular and
its margins may be continuous with the enlarged liver
surface. It may be firm to begin with, but later may
become fluctuant. Often there is a bulge in the right
infra-axillary region.
Tenderness
Tenderness may be diffuse or localised. However, both
may occur together, one being superimposed on the other.
Diffuse tenderness is elicited by striking a gentle blow
to the right lower chest with the palmar surface of the
clenched fist (Fig.1). The whole right lower
chest, starting anteriorly and moving posteriorly should
be struck, by this Punch test. If the liver
is palpable, subcostal tenderness should be looked for by
pressing that area with the palmar surface of the fingers
before and after deep inspiration. Diffuse liver
tenderness can also be elicited by the compression
sign - that is tenderness on antero-posterior
compression of the lower part of the chest on the right
side12 (Fig.2)
A localised area of maximum tenderness must be looked
for. This area may lie subcostally; if not, it is often
found by thumb pressure in the intercostal space (Fig.3). This intercostal
tenderness is one of the cardinal signs of liver
abscess.
Much more informative is the point
tenderness, which is noted more often than
generalised intercostal tenderness. Point
tenderness (Fig. 4) is elicited by palpating
with the tips of the fingers all over the hepatic area
including the right lower chest (anterior and posterior
and subcostal area. As against intercostal tenderness
which could be present in pleurisy etc., point tenderness
is more diagnostic of liver abscess and is also a useful
guide as to the side for abscess puncture. Point
tenderness and intercostal tenderness are often elicited
even in the absence of diffuse liver tenderness. The
former is often elicited in the postero-lateral area of a
lower right intercostal space (Fig. 4).
Lamont and Pooler21 graded the tenderness into
the following categories :
- Grade 0-I :
Patients who have no tenderness or who have to be
questioned specifically about it.
- Grade I :
Moderate tenderness due to which the patient
winces in response to gentle palpation or
percussion.
- Grade II :
Severe tenderness due to which the patient moves
away from the examining hand.
- Grade III :
Very severe tenderness due to which the patient
refrains from the examining hand even before it
reaches the affected area.
In their series of
250 cases most patients (45.2%) had Grade II tenderness.
10.4% had Grade 0-I , 37.2% Grade I, while 7.2% had Grade
III tenderness.
Another important localising sign is the presence of
oedema overlying the ribs, costal margin and anterior
abdominal wall. Most often because of a raised right dome
of the diaphragm, there is an impaired percussion note,
diminished air entry and occasional crepitations at the
right base.
A hepatic rub may be elicited in some cases. However, it
is a rare finding. In those cases where air has been
instilled after tapping, hepatic succussion splash could
be elicited.
Rarely, in some patients there may neither be
hepatomegaly nor tenderness.35
General signs
The general signs are less important in the diagnosis
of amoebic liver abscess (except fever which has already
been discussed). On general examination, apart from
pyrexia and sweating, a muddy look has been described. It
is difficult to appreciate this in Indian patients,
though when present, these patients are markedly wasted
and the onset of their illness is usually chronic.
Icterus may be detected in a few cases if one looks for
it specifically and in good natural light. Rarely
swelling of the feet, mild ascites, clubbing of the
nails, or signs of hepatic coma may be present.
In many patients the colon when palpated is tender. This
tenderness is maximum over the caecum. I have often seen
a tender hepatic flexure, being confused with hepatic
tenderness. Patients having concurrent dysentery, or who
had it in the recent past will have a diffuse colonic
tenderness.
Criteria for diagnosis
Since the days of Roger, the diagnosis of hepatic
amoebiasis was made with confidence, at the bedside, in a
patient with a history of dysentery and the presence of a
painful tender hepatomegaly. In 1958, Lamont and Pooler21 proposed five diagnostic
criteria for hepatic amoebiasis.
- Tender,
enlarged liver
- Suggestive
haematological findings
- Suggestive
radiological findings
- Demonstration
of characteristic pus
- Successful
antiamoebic drug therapy
In 1978, Quaderi et
al36 enlarged upon these and
divided them into major and minor criteria for the
diagnosis of amoebic liver abscess. The major criteria
are the ones suggested by the WHO.37 These include :
- Enlarged
tender liver
- Radiological
evidence of raised dome of the diaphragm
- Fever and
polymorphonuclear leucocytosis
- A cold area on
liver scanning (which is to be done prior to
aspiration)
- Aspiration of
amoebic pus from the liver abscess
The minor criteria
include :
- Residence in
an endemic area
- Presence of
fever
- A muddy
complexion
- Fullness of
right lower intercostal spaces
- Polymorphonuclear
leucocytosis
- Demonstration
of E. Histolytica from pathology specimen
- Presence of
amoebic ulcers of large bowel on sigmoidoscopy
Of all these
criteria mentioned above, aspiration of sterile pus from
the liver constitutes the absolute proof of an amoebic
liver abscess. To this we should now add demonstration of
E. Histolytica in the pus and a positive serological test
for amoebiasis.
Once amoebic liver abscess is suspected, therapeutic
trial with chloroquine or metronidazole should be started
while proceeding to confirm the diagnosis by various
investigations available.
Localisation
of an abscess is always the second step once the
diagnosis of an amoebic liver abscess has been made.
Although in centres where a liver scan is available, the
clue might be obtained easily, still efforts must be made
to localise it at the bed side. The following chapters
deal with this problem
References
- Aptekar,
S J, and Sood, I D, Ind. J. Surg., 1970, 32, 169.
- DeBakey,
M E, and Ochsner, A, Surg Gyn. Obst. (I.A.S.),
1951, 92, 209.
- Raghavan,
P. Kurein, J. et al, J. Ass. Phys. Ind., 1961, 9,
568.
- Soragg,
J. Arch, Dis. Child., 1960, 35,171.
- Manson-Bahr,
P H. Manson's Tropical Diseases, Cassell &
Co. Publications, London, 1967.
- Samsi,
A B. and Patwardhan, N A, J. Surg., 1974 36, 1
37.
- Turrill,
F L, and Burnham, I R. Am. J. Surg., 1966, 111,
424.
- Rouis,
as quoted by Vergoz, P. and Hermanjat Cuerin, R P
1932.
- Ramachandran,
S. Goonatillake, H D, et al, Brit. J. Surg.,
1976, 63, 220.
- Ochsner,
A, and DeBakey, M E, Surgery., 1943, 13, 460.
- Ochsner,
A, and DeBakey, M E, Surgery., 1943, 13, 612.
- Craig,
C F. The Etiology, Diagnosis and Treatment of
Amoebiasis, Williams & Wilkins Co.,
Baltimore, 1944, 150
- Mallory,
W J. J. Am Med. Ass., 1920, 75, 1774.
- Ochsner,
A, and Debakey, M E, J. Thoracic Surg., 1936 5,
285.
- Ludlow,
A J, Clin. Med. J., 1926, 40, 1165.
- Subramaniam,
R. Krishnan, K T. et al, J. Ass Phys. Ind.. 1970,
18, 729.
- Ramachandran,
S. Sivalingam, S. et al, J Trop. Med. Hyg., 1972,
75, 23.
- Klatskin,
G. Ann. Int. Med ,1946, 25, 601.
- Rajasuriya,
K, and Nagaratnam, N. J. Trop. Med. Hyg., 1962,
65, 165.
- Anderson,
N H. Bostick. W L, et al, Amoebiasis Pathology,
Diagnosis and Chemotherapy, Charles C. Thomas
Publication, Springfield, 1953,131.
- Lamont,
N M, and Pooler, N R. Quart. J. Med., 1958, 27,
389.
- Stuiver,
P C, and Gond, T J. Brit. Med. J., 1978, 2, 394.
- Habibullah,
C M, Ramachandran, R S. et al, J. Ind. Med. Ass,
1977, 69, 247.
- DeBakev,
M E, and Jordan, I, Schiff's Dlseases of the
Liver, J. B. Lippincott & Co., London, 1975.
- Wilmot,
A J. Clinical Amoebiasis, Blackwell Scientific
Publications. Oxford, 1962.
- Harinasuta,
T. Bunnag, D, et al, VlIlth Internat. Cong. Trop.
Med. Malaria, Abstracts and review, Tehran, 1968,
258.
- Banker,
D D, Ind. Physician, 1947, 6, 254.
- Subramaniam,
R. and Madangopalan, N. Amoebiasis, Sandoz's
Monograph, 1970.
- Madangopalan,
N. Progress in Clinical Medicine in India, Arnold
Heinemann Publishers, India, 1976.
- Shabot,
J M, and Patterson, M, Am. J. Dig. Dis., 1978,
23, 110.
- Patterson,
M, and Lawlis, V, Am. Pract., 1956, 7, 1995.
- Chaves,
F J. Cruz, I, et al, Am. J. Gastroent., 1977, 68,
134.
- Omer,
A H S. J. Trop. Med Hyg., 1972, 75, 42.
- Ansari,
Z A, S'karid, J. et al, J Trop Med. Hyg., 1973,
76, 169.
- Bockus,
H L, Gastroenterology, Vol. IV, 3rd Edition, W B
Saunders & Co., Philad., 1976
- Quaderi,
M A, Rahaman, M S. et al, J. Trop. Med. Hyg.,
1978, 81, 17.
- Savanat
T. and Wanpen C, WHO Bull., WHO, 1969, 40, 343
|