. |
Amoebic
liver abscess of the left lobe is relatively less common
than the right lobe.1-3 Rogers recorded that, of
the amoebic liver abscess cases in European hospitals,
left lobe formed 11.9%, while in the Indian medical
college hospitals the incidence was 18.3%. According to
Manson-Bahr, only 10-15% of amoebic liver abscess occur
in the left lobe.4 In our series we found an
incidence of 12%.
Table I shows incidence of the left lobe abscess in other
series.
TABLE I
| Incidence of left
lobe abscess |
| Author |
Year |
Total no. of
cases
Clinical / Autopsy
|
Percentage |
| Ochsner and DeBakey5 |
1939 |
4030 (Autopsy+ Clinical) |
16.1 |
| Ochsner and DeBakey6 |
1943 |
140 (Clinical) |
4.0 |
| Clark7 |
1945 |
95 (Autopsy) |
8.0 |
| Chatterjee |
1954 |
225 (Clinical) |
18.9 |
| Lamont and Pooler' |
1958 |
240 (Clinical) |
16.0 |
| Alkan9 |
1961 |
28 (Clinical) |
18.0 |
| Doshi et al2 |
1965 |
20 (Clinical) |
5.0 |
| Ramachandran10 |
1974 |
74 (Clinical) |
18.9 |
| Kapoor |
|
200 (Clinical) |
12.0 |
Based
on the arterial supply and the accompanying hepatic
ducts, the anatomical left lobe is the lateral segment of
the left lobe. It is situated in the epigastrium and left
subcostal area. Anteriorly it is partly covered by the
left costal margin and only a part of it presents itself
to the clinician for palpation in the epigastrium. Its
superior surface is closely related to the central
tendinous part of the diaphragm and part of the left
cusp, which separates it from the pericardium, heart,
left pleural cavity and the left lung. Its inferior
surface is related to the stomach, duodenum and the
transverse colon. It is closely related to five potential
spaces into which pus may collect in the event of rupture
of amoebic abscess of the left lobe. These are: (1) the
pericardial sac, (2) the left pleural cavity, (3) the
left subphrenic space, (4) the general peritoneal cavity
and (5) the lesser sac of the peritoneum.
An amoebic abscess of the left lobe may form, either near
its superior, or inferior surface. Because of the
potentially greater space in the left subcostal area, an
abscess near the superior surface may remain occult or
its symptoms and signs may remain relatively vague until
it attains a significant size.11 On the other hand if the
abscess is superficial, it may rupture into the thorax,
before attaining a large size. The clinical picture may
then be dominated completely by symptoms and signs of the
complications resulting from the rupture of the abscess
with little or no evidence of the existence of the
abscess. As the abdominal cavity offers less resistance,
downward extension is seen more frequently in a left lobe
abscess.4 An abscess in the inferior part of
the lobe may devour the substance of the liver and
(because of the small mass of the left lobe) quickly
reach the anterior or inferior surface, making rupture
imminent.
Therefore, the incidence of secondary involvement of the
adjoining organs and other complications is higher in
cases involving the left lobe rather than the right.4
On account of the above-mentioned anatomical
peculiarities, amoebic abscess of the left lobe produces
clinical syndromes which are not only distinct but also
of varied nature, as compared to the right lobe abscess
in which clinical features are more constant.9 Paul11 was one of the earliest to
recognise this fact.
Syndromes produced by amoebic liver abscess of the left
lobe are described below. It must be kept in mind that
although the abscess can occur predominantly in the
superior or inferior surface, an abscess of the left lobe
often involves both the surfaces (Fig. 56) and thus produces a combined
picture.12 Also when the abscess is in
the superior surface, the rest of the left lobe is quite
often enlarged so as to be palpable in the epigastrium. A
co-existing abscess in the right lobe is also common and
should not be overlooked. This has been stressed in the
chapter on multiple amoebic liver abscesses.
Clinical syndromes produced by left lobe abscess can be
classified into-
"Clinical syndromes"
produced by an inferior surface abscess of the left lobe
- Enlarged
tender left lobe.
- Small
superficial lump in an enlarged left lobe.
- Large
intrahepatic abscess producing a big lump in the
epigastrium.
- Rupture of
abscess with localization.
- Rupture of
abscess with generalized peritonitis.
- Abscess of the
caudate lobe.
II. "Clinical syndromes"
produced by superior surface abscess of the left lobe
- Uncomplicated
superior surface abscess (U.S.S.S.L.L.L.A.L.A.
syndrome).
- Complicated
superior surface abscess whiz may present as-
- Amoebic
pericarditis.
- Left
pleuropulmonary amoebiasis.
- Combination of
left pleuropulmonar amoebiasis and amoebic
pericarditis.
I. "Clinical syndromes"
produced by an inferior surface abscess of the left lobe
- Enlarged
tender left lobe. An enlarged tender left lobe is
palpable in the epigastrium and the left
hypochondrium, which moves very well with
respiration (Fig. 57). No lump is seen or
palpated. Patient complains of upper abdominal
pain or discomfort of varying intensity. Pain is
aggravated by respiratory movements or Iying in
left lateral position. Liver scan shows a cold
area on the inferior surface of the left lobe (Fig. 58). Radiological
investigations may not provide any further
information of value, but serological tests and
peritoneoscopy would help. If necessary,
aspiration can be done safely per abdomen.
- Small
superficial lump in an enlarged left lobe. These
patients have a soft tender lump within the
enlarged left lobe (Fig. 59). The lump may be
palpable in the epigastrium or brought out from
under the left costal margin by deep inspiration
or by turning the patient to a right lateral
positioned. This lump moves well with
respiration, as the abscess is well localised
within the liver unlike one in which rupture is
imminent.11 Liver scan shows a
cold area on the inferior surface of the left
lobe (Fig. 60). However, the
radiological investigations may be negative.
Serological tests and peritoneoscopy would also
help in the diagnosis. Since these lumps can
always rupture, they should all be aspirated per
abdomen (Fig. 59)
- Large
intrahepatic abscess producing a big lump in
epigastrium. The abscess is sufficiently
large in size to produce a space-occupying mass
in the epigastric and left subcostal region (Figs. 61 a,b). The entire left lobe may be
destroyed and replaced by the abscess.9 The lump is tender
and smooth but still moves with respiration. It
causes compression or vascular congestion of the
adjoining organs causing additional symptoms such
as nausea, vomiting and diarrhoea and signs like
prominent epigastric veins and obliteration of
Traube's space. Some of these abscesses also
extend in a backward and upward direction. Such
patients may complain of referred pain at the tip
of the left shoulder due to irritation of the
left hemidiaphragm.14 Low dysphagia due
to displacement of intra-abdominal portion of the
oesophagus has also been reported.14 If the abscess
extends mainly backwards, it appears to be deep
seated on palpation. Such cases have been wrongly
diagnosed as perigastric abscess, left perirenal
abscess or rolled up omentum.2,4 A case in which the
lump transmitted the pulsations of aorta and was
initially misdiagnosed as aneurysm of the
abdominal aorta, has been recorded.2 In chronic or
partially treated cases, signs of inflammation
may be absent and the lump may be firm and
irregular akin to hepatic carcinoma14 Apart from liver
scan (Fig. 62), peritoneoscopy and
radiological investigations also may furnish
diagnostic information in this group of patients.
Our policy is to aspirate all the huge left lobe
abscesses per abdomen as early as possible. This
is because rupture is more likely in the left
lobe abscess. For the same reason, in the past,
they were submitted to open surgery. Many
authorities are now convinced that tapping per
abdomen is quite a "safe" procedure.
- Rupture of
abscess with localization. Sometimes the
abscess leaks into the peritoneal cavity but gets
walled off quickly thus forming a localised
abscess.14 Depending
upon the site of leakage, the abscess may get
localised to the left anterior subphrenic space,
left posterior subphrenic space or the left
infrahepatic region.14 The abscess may
communicate with the lesser sac without soiling
the peritoneal cavity.9 it may form
adhesions with diaphragm, anterior abdominal
wall, stomach, duodenum, transverse colon,
omentum, etc.9
The physical signs depend on the site of
localisation. A tender irregular lump (Fig. 63) is palpable in the
epigastrium and left hypochondrium, sometimes
extending towards the umbilicus. The movements
with respiration are markedly restricted due to
adhesions11,14 Radiological signs
are of great help in ascertaining the size and
site of the abscess. This would be complemented
by peritoneoscopy and liver scan. Serological
tests, if positive in high titre, are very
useful.
Though some of these patients would need open
drainage, many of them can be aspirated even at
this stage with good results.
- Rupture of
abscess with generalised peritonitis. This
results in acute abdomen which has already been
discussed elsewhere. Laparotomy has always to be
performed in these cases. The picture of
pre-rupture syndrome is not seen in left lobe
abscesses .
- Abscess of
the caudate lobe. As explained earlier this
is the medial part of the left lobe. An abscess
in this area is generally silent, till it leaks
into the lesser sac, when it produces a painful
epigastric swelling.
A number of radiological signs have been
described in left lobe amoebic abscess.15-17 Following are the
radiological features which may be present in
large "inferior" surface abscesses:
- Plain X-ray of
the abdomen may show-
- soft tissue
mass in the epigastrium and left hypochondrium14 (Fig. 64).
- downward
displacement of the transverse colon (Fig. 65).
- Barium meal
studies of the stomach and duodenum may show the
following appearances:
- a well-defined
concave (extrinsic pressured defect on the lesser
Curvature2 (Fig. 66).
- (a localised
crescenteric deformity of the lesser curvature (Fig. 67).
- stretching and
rounding of the lesser curvature around the mass
with its displacement to the left (Fig. 68).
- lateral view
of the barium filled stomach may show posterior
displacement of the stomach (Fig. 69) with or without
indentation of the anterior surface producing a
sickle-like appearances9 (Fig. 70).
- forward
displacement of the stomach.9
- downward
displacement of the duodenal bulb and medial
displacement of the second part of the duodenum18(Fig. 70).
The following three
signs on plain X-ray or barium meal study are usually
seen with superior surface abscess but may also be seen
in a large inferior surface abscess.
- downward
displacement of the cardia of the stomach 12,18
- a filling
defect in the fundus of the stomach14 (due to extrinsic
pressure).
- elongation and
posterior displacement of intra-abdominal portion
of the oesophagus.14
- Barium enema
may show downward and forward displacement of the
splenic flexure of the colon.5
- X-ray chest is
usually normal. But the following findings may be
noted:
- Elevation of
the right dome of the diaphragm may be seen in
cases of left lobe abscess. In the author's
experience, this is always due to a co-existing
right lobe abscess.11 Other causes like
generalised hepatic congestion1or diffuse amoebic
hepatitis19 are highly unlikely
and were mentioned formerly, when liver scans
were not available.
- Elevation of
the left dome of the diaphragm -This occurs more
often in the case of superior surface abscess due
to direct pressure of the expanding lesion.
However, we have found this sign to be present
even in case of inferior surface abscess.16 The likely
mechanisms for the elevation in the latter cases
are:
- upward
displacement and distension of the stomach
compressed by an enlarged left lobe.
- upward
displacement of the loops of the splenic flexure.
- adhesions of
the loops of the colon following a leak from the
abscess producing partial obstruction and
distension (Figs. 72 a,b).
- lastly as in
the case of the right lobe, rarely the left dome
gets elevated by a huge inferior surface abscess
of the left lobe (Fig. 73).
Role of peritoneoscopy in
the diagnosis
In groups 1 and 2 liver scan often helps in the
diagnosis. But from group 3 onwards, liver scan is a poor
investigation to differentiate a left lobe liver abscess
from other upper abdominal lumps. In these cases the cold
area seen in the left lobe could be due to an
extrahepatic mass. So often have these mistakes been made
that , in the author's opinion, peritoneoscopy in such
patients is much more superior and informative than a
liver scan. If both investigations are available, both
must be done.20 For example, though
peritoneoscopy may show a huge inferior surface abscess
of the left lobe, a second abscess in the posterior
portion of the right lobe may be missed. The latter would
also be picked up on a liver scan.
Clinical syndromes produced by superior surface abscess
of the left lobe have been discussed in the next few
chapters.
References
- Lamont,
N M, and Pooler, N R. Quart. J Med. 1958, 27,
389.
- Doshi,
J C, Ind. J Med. Sci., 1965, 19, 670.
- Ghosh,
B C, Ind. Med. Gaz., 1954, 89, 152.
- Manson-Bahr,
P. Proc. Roy Soc. Med. 1932, 25, 233.
- Ochsner,
A, and DeBakey, M E, Surg. Gyn. Obst., (I.A.S.),
1939, 69, 392.
- Ochsner,
A, and DeBakey, M E, Surgery, 1943,13, 460.
- Clark,
R H. and Dutta, D K, Ind. Med Gaz., 1945, 80 554
- Chatterjee,
as quoted by Ghosh, B C.
- Alkan,
W J. Kalmi, B. et al, Ann Int Med., 1961, 55,
800.
- Ramachandran,
S. Post-Grad Med J, 1974, 50 689.
- Paul,
M, Brit J Surg., 1960, 47, 502
- Kapoor,
O P and Shah, N A, Paper read at the Xl
International Congress of Internal Medicine New
Delhi, Oct 1970
- Kapoor,
O P. Bom Hosp J., 1963, 5, 12
- Rasaretnam,
R. and Wijetilaka, S E, Post-Grad. Med J, 1976,
52, 269.
- Rowland,
H A, I Trop Med. Hyg, 1963, 66, 113
- Kapoor,
O P. and Shah, N A, Ind J Chest Dis., 1972, 14,
237
- Harley,
H R. Proc Roy Soc Med., 1970, 63, 319
- DeBakey,
M E, and Ochsner, A, Surg Gyn Obst (I A S ),
1951, 92, 209
- Ramachandran,
S. Sivalingam, S. et al, J Trop. Med. Hyg, 1973,
76, 39.
- Udwadia,
T E, Personal communication.
|