Bombay Hospital Journal ContentsHomeArchivesSearchBooksFeedback


Home > Table of Contents > Original / research
 
Facing The Challenges of Adolescent Reproductive Health - Is Counselling The Answer?
Suchitra N Pandit*, Sachin J Dalal**, Sanjay B Rao***, Arti Narayanswamy**
 

Abstract
Aims : 1) Ensuring greater availability and accessibility of services for promotion of adolescent reproductive health thereby improving the status of adolescent girls. 2) To assess the level of knowledge and attitude of adolescent girls towards menstruation, ovulation and sexual behaviour and analyze the need for a counselling centre.

Material and Methods : 1) Preparation of a structured questionnaire. 2) Focus group discussion with parents having adolescent daughters. 3) Training interviewers. 4) Pilot testing. 5) Data collection by interviewing 880 girls.

Results : 1) 93.2 % girls had attained menarche. 34.5% expressed fear and 35.1% had no reaction to the onset of menses. 2) 61.6% girls had knowledge of contraception. 3) 72.9% knew that unprotected sex would lead to pregnancy. 4) 68.65% knew about sexual intercourse and 60.2% knew that condoms could prevent HIV infection. 5) 93.2% girls wanted a counseling centre and 56% felt that it should be in a school.

 

Introduction
The physiological transition from childhood to adulthood during adolescence is a period of great strife. This transition has always tended to be sudden for young girls. Genetic, health and socio-economic factors have an influence on the wide variations in the age of menarche in India. There is also evidence that menarche is delayed due to poor nutritional status of the average Indian adolescent girl, thereby delaying the biological onset of adolescence. On the other hand, due to early marriage and consequently the onset of sexual activity, pregnancy and child-bearing occur relatively early, thereby propelling the girl into early adulthood even before physical maturity is attained.

Adolescents are faced with different choices in sexual behaviour – premarital sex, early marriage or abstinence. The young girl in India is primarily ‘at risk’ because of lack of information and having little or no access to sexual and reproductive health services. Communication between parents and adolescents has also greatly decreased. In addition to this, the existing health services and system have largely ignored the reproductive health needs of the adolescents. Information and services should be made available to the adolescents to help them understand their sexuality and protect them from premarital sex, unwanted pregnancies and sexually transmitted diseases (STDs).

Aims and Objectives

  1. To determine and assess the level of knowledge and attitude of adolescent girls (11 – 19 years) towards menstruation, ovulation, safe sex, contraception, STDs and HIV.
  2. To identify their source of knowledge and assess their health seeking potential.
  3. To determine the need for a structured counselling programme and the choice of location, counsellor and the time for counselling services.

Material and Methods
The study included 880 adolescent girls from the high schools and junior colleges of Mumbai, Pune and Manipal, Karnataka. Focus group discussions were conducted with a group of parents having adolescent daughters with a pre-prepared structured questionnaire. The interviewers were trained and pilot testing was done with 25 girls following which the questionnaire was further modified. All the girls interviewed were assured that the information given would remain confidential.

Results

  • Analysis of education and occupational status showed that 424 (48.2%) girls were in junior college, 193 (21.98%) were employed and only 3 (0.4%) were illiterate.
  • 542 (61.6%) adolescents knew about contraception. Amongst them, 91 (16.8%) had a good knowledge and 401 (74%) had average knowledge.
  • 465 (39.5%) girls knew that unprotected sex can cause Reproductive Tract Infections (RTI), STDs and HIV. 280 (60.2%) had knowledge that condoms could prevent HIV infection. Mothers [118 – 25.4%], friends [121 – 26.2%] and schools [100-21.5%] were the most important sources of information.
  • 61 girls had suffered from symptoms suggestive of RTI / STDs. Of these girls, 10 had taken treatment from a Gynaecologist, 7 from a general hospital and 2 had self–medication.
  • 420 (47.7%) girls knew the significance of the safe period. This was told to them mostly by mothers [130-31.7%] and schools [144- 34.3%].
  • 348 (39.5%) teenagers felt the need to be educated about the physiology of menstruation and ovulation. 182 (20.7%) wanted to know more about contraception and 109 (12.4%) desired to be told about RTIs. 587 (66.7%) preferred to get the information by reading some material and 767 (87.2%) wanted sex education to be a part of the regular high school curriculum. 614 (69.8%) desired summer school camps and 501 (56.9%) wanted access to a 24 hour telephone hotline service.
  • 641 (72.9%) knew that unprotected sex would lead to pregnancy. Of the 20 girls who had become pregnant, 4 opted for continuation of pregnancy and 16 underwent MTP. Only 8 girls had been counselled about contraception after undergoing MTP.
Table 1 : Age of the teenagers according to marital status
Age group
(years)
Married Unmarried Total No.
(%)
10 – 13 02 93 95 (10.8)
13 – 16 08 279 287 (32.6)
16 – 19 22 476 498 (56.6)
Total 32 848 880 (100)

Table 2 : Knowledge about sexual intercourse
Parameters No. of Teenagers Percentage
Knowledge about sexual intercourse
Poor 267 30.3
Average 495 56.3
Good 118 13.4
Source of knowledge
Mother 250 28.4
Sister 181 20.6
Friends 226 25.7
School 139 15.8
Magazine 47 05.3
Husband 02 0.2
Boyfriend 07 0.8
Others 28 3.2
Criteria adopted for level of knowledge
Poor: practically no knowledge
Average: knowledge about the sex act.
Good: knowledge about masturbation, penetrative and non-penetrative sex
Table 3 : Knowledge about Menstruation and Ovulation
Parameters No. of Teenagers Percentage
Menarche attained
Yes
No
820
60
93.2
06.8
First reaction to menarche
Morbid fear
Apprehension
Happiness
Satisfaction
Mixed
None
52
283
38
37
32
97
06.3
34.5
04.6
04.5
03.8
11.2
No of Years since menarche
1-2
2-3
3-4
4-5
159
171
170
320
19.4
20.9
20.7
39.0
Knowledge of Menstruation
Poor
Average
Good
72
480
328
08.2
54.5
37.3
Source of knowledge
Mother
Sister
Friends
School
Husband
Other
438
219
84
129
2
8
49.8
24.9
09.5
14.6
0.3
0.9
Table 4 : Knowledge of symptoms suggestive of RTI/ STD
Knowledge of Symptoms
Suggestive of Rti / Std
No. of Girls Percentage No. Having
Symptoms
1. Intense white discharge P/V
124 14.1 34
2. Burning micturition
48 3.4 17
3. Genital swelling
30 3.4 03
4. Genital ulcers
28 3.2 02
5. Pain in the groin 5 7.4 05

Discussion

In the present series of 880 teenage girls, 498 (56.6%) were in the 16 – 19 years age group, 39 % had attained menarche since 4 – 5 years. At menarche, the reaction of these girls varied from shock to neutral feelings – bearing a direct correlation to the extent of prior knowledge and sounding about the same. Mothers, friends and schools were the key information providers. Many mothers impart information to their daughters about menstruation, but feel shy or awkward about sex-education. In most instances, only the mechanics of menstruation related to behavioural norms (not permitted to cook or go close to the idols of Gods)4 are talked about, rather than the physical and physiological changes occurring in the body and their relationship to sex and reproduction.5 Denial of this important knowledge in this important stage of life is a major contributory factor towards ignorance about contraception, pregnancy, child-bearing and maternal morbidity and mortality. Hence, though sex education is vital for adolescents, social taboos and stigmas prevent access to such information.6

Table 5 : Information about Counselling centres
Parameters No. of Teenagers Percentage
Want a Centre 820 93.2
Do not want a Centre 60 06.8
Services to be free 728 87.6
Services be charged 92 11.2
Location
School / college 460 56.1
Private clinics 144 17.6
Hospital premises 140 17.0
Mahila mandals 76 09.3
Prefer to have
Female counsellors 660 80.6
Male counsellors 20 02.4
Both 60 07.3
No preference 80 09.7
Prefer to have
Young counsellor 300 36.6
Middle aged 465 56.7
Old counsellors 55 06.7
Timings of the centre
8 am – 12 noon 130 15.8
1 pm – 5 pm 321 39.1
4 pm – 10 pm 204 24.8
no specific opinion 104 20.1
Prefer to have
Week days 137 16.7
Weekends 292 35.6
Both 70 08.6
No opinion 321 39.1

In the present study, 465 (52.8%) teenagers knew that unprotected sex leads to Reproductive Tract Infection (RTI). 460 (52.3%) had no idea about ‘Safe period’. 115 (13.1%) knew about the symptoms suggestive of STDs and 97 (11%) knew the symptoms of RTIs. A similar study conducted by Jasmine Prasad et al at the Community Health Department, Christian Medical College, Vellore also concluded that the knowledge on menstrual hygiene, contraception and safe sex practices was poor and stressed the importance of sex education of adolescents.9 The most significant finding in our study was that 820 girls (86.2%) strongly voiced their desire for access to a counselling centre. Recent research in western countries reveals that STDs and contraception were the subjects most frequently discussed with the nurses and doctors.

Conclusion

  • Adolescents (11- 19 years) must be given due importance and must be recognised as a priority target group in terms of age, education, occupation and level of knowledge of reproductive physiology.
  • A structured counselling programme could play a cardinal role in making young girls more responsible about their sexual behaviour.
  • Young girls need to be encouraged and facilitated to ask questions and seek information.
  • Adolescent Health Counselling centres should be developed at various places manned by trained and friendly counsellors assuring confidentiality without being moralizing.
  • Mothers play an important role in shaping adolescent behaviour and values.
  • 24 hour Hotline services manned by trained personnel would be beneficial.
  • Adolescent reproductive health programmes should be inculcated in the National Family Planning Programme. Parents also should be offered education so that they can be sensitive to their children’s needs.

References

  1. Jeejeebhoy Shireen – Soc Sci Med 1998; 10 :1275.
  2. International Institute of Population Sciences (1995). National Family Health Survey (MCH and Family Planning): India: 1992-1993, Bombay.
  3. Aneeta Kulkarni. MSW Dissertation, Tata Institute of Social Sciences, 1985.
  4. Bhende A. A study of sexuality of adolescent girls and boys in underprivileged group in Bombay. Ind J Soc Work LV 1994; 4 : 557–71.
  5. Vlassof C. Educating female adolescent possibilities and limitations for social change and populations learning in rural India. Demog Ind 1978; 7 (1-2) : 175 -93.
  6. Sunanda KS. Grass – roots action, Special issue on girl-child, issue 3, April 1990, 4 p source: Child Relief and you.
  7. Epstein R, Rice P, Wallave P. Teenagers health concerns: implications for primary health care professionals. J R Coll Gen Pract 1989; 39 : 247-9.
  8. Suchitra N. Pandit. Teenage pregnancy – Unmet needs for a counselling centre (a pilot study): Reports of participants: Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights: Advanced Training Programme part 2 Dhaka, Bangladesh, 1999: Pg 174.
  9. Jasmine Prasad: Reproductive Health education for adolescents. Reports of participants: Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights: Advanced Training Programme part 2 Dhaka, Bangladesh, 1999: Pg 193.

PRIMARY VERSUS FACILITATED PCI

‘Might any subgroups benefit from facilitated angioplasty’

Facilitated percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) is defined as the use of a pharmacological substance before a planned, immediate PCI procedure. Although preliminary studies have not shown a benefit of facilitated PCI in the treatment of ST-segment-elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI), patients are being treated with the procedure in everyday clinical practice in many countries.

In the first of two Articles this week, the ASSENT-4 PCI trial was undertaken to investigate whether full-dose tenecteplase in a facilitated approach before a delayed PCI would alleviate the negative effect of this delay, and be more effective than a delayed primary approach. The researchers had to stop the trial early because of higher in-hospital mortality in the facilitated PCI group than in the primary PCI group, and therefore could not recommend the tenecteplase strategy.

In a quantitative review of 17 trials, Ellen Keeley and colleagues did a pooled analysis to compare the primary approach with the facilitated approach. They found that facilitated PCI had shown no benefit over primary PCI, and emphasised that thrombolytic-based regimens should be avoided.

In a Comment, Gregg Stone and Bernard Gersh are unsurprised by the results of this quantitative review; they relate their disappointment with the non-benefit of facilitated PCI, despite the initial theoretical promise and interest in the strategy, and they discuss future interventions for delayed PCI.

Lancet, 2006; 543, 569, 579.

 
*Associate Professor and Unit In- Charge; **Registrar; ***Lecturer; **Dept. of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Lokmanya Tilak Municipal Medical College and General Hospital, Sion, Mumbai.
Top